Recently I was asked by Garth Connelly to do a build review of the Merit 1/48 scale late war 80’ Elco PT boat. I was also asked to build it out of the
box and to use the acrylic paint set that is also distributed by Merit and contains the colors needed for a measure 31/20L camo scheme which calls for
dark green # 2, dark green # 3, dull black, deck green, and anti-fouling red for the hull underside.  I agreed to do the build and am now giving my
feedback from this project.

The kit consists of plastic parts, clear acetate parts for the deck structure windows and searchlight lens, and photo etch parts for the two tables on the
sides of the front and rear structures, the radar antenna, radio antenna, navigation light panels, 40mm gun sights, and ammo locker hardware. The parts
have very little flash and very few sink marks. The small amount of flash that I encountered was easily removed, and there were only a few sink marks
that would be visible after assembly, but which were easily filled and sanded. Many of the tubing and railing parts had several sprue gates on them, so
extra care must be taken when removing the parts from the sprue and when cleaning them for assembly and painting. The fit was mostly excellent, but
you need to make sure you check the fit of the torpedoes in their respective racks to ensure that you will be able to slide the completed and painted
torpedo into the completed and painted rack.  You need to take the paint thickness into consideration to avoid damaging the painted torpedo. The most
fitting trouble I encountered was putting the 50 cal gun assemblies together, as they have several parts that must be exactly located, and then the gun
assembly then attaches to the gun ring and front tubular structure. If you take the time to dry-fit the parts and confirm the hole sizes that you drill
before you assemble the parts and sub-assemblies you will not run into any trouble with the build. There is a minimum of seam filling needed, but you
will need to fill the seams for the 50 cal gun tubs and the four torpedoes, all of which are similar to an airplane fuselage in shape and will not look
authentic with visible seams running down their length.

Although there are injection sink marks on the inside of the 50 cal turret assemblies, they are not visible when the machine guns are attached to the tubs.
My biggest squawk for the entire build is the color info sheet, which is unclear regarding which areas are dull black and dark green, and has incorrect
color call outs for the deck color and the nav lights (port & starboard). The dark green and black portions of the camo scheme are virtually
indistinguishable in the drawings, and some areas of the colors have the color tag, but others do not. With the dark green color and the dull black colors
being almost the same on the instruction sheet, it will be difficult to determine where one color stops and the other begins. For an experienced modeler
that shouldn't pose too great of a problem but a novice will be confused, in my opinion. The colored instruction sheet also only lists where to put the
bow water depth markings decal and the flag decal, but doesn’t list the location of the numbers for the hull sides, deck structures, or the transom
numbers and transom water depth markings.  Again, an experienced modeler wouldn’t be troubled by the omissions, but a first-timer may run into some
problems.  The construction sheet also has its own problems, the main ones being that in step #3 on page 5, the center prop shaft part number is J14,
which is incorrect. The correct part number should be H14.  On step #22 on page 13, the two deck hatch numbers are reversed. J14 actually is the
more forward hatch, and H4 goes just in front of the front deck structure. The two parts are very similar in size and shape, and I only caught the
problem when I dry fitted both parts. The illustrations could be a little bit clearer with the 50 cal gun assemblies also.  Luckily I built the Italeri 1/35
scale kit and was familiar with how everything should attach.
I built and painted the kit in a series of sub-assemblies.  The weapons are nicely detailed and the 40mm gun is a mini-kit in itself.  After all the sub-
assemblies were painted, I attached them to the deck and then attached the deck to the completed and painted hull assembly. The acrylic paints that are
designed for the kit airbrush and brush very nicely. It was my first attempt at spraying an entire model using acrylics (I usually use solvent based
finishes) and I was favorably impressed with the way the paints handled and covered.  I did not have any problems when masking the base colors for
the camo and waterline applications. I hand masked the camo scheme, but I would contact Kenny Loup at Gatormasks to see if he has a set of masks
for this kit, as I used his product for the Italeri build and it worked very well.  In addition to the main colors I listed above, the paint set also includes a
brass color for the props.  All the colors seem to look “right” to me with the exception of the prop color which seems a little bit too orangey, in my
opinion.  I sprayed the guns Floquil Weathered Black, the prop shafts and rudders Alclad Steel, and the torpedo bodies and props Alclad Pale Burnt
Metal to try and replicate a natural metal body that had protective grease applied to it.  The warheads were painted the base green color. White warheads
would have indicated practice torpedoes.

The decal sheet has six rows of small numbers (for the hulls sides and three positions on the front deck structure) and two rows of large numbers for
the transom, transom and hull water depth markings, and two US flags. Unless you intend to use a number like 555, or other multiple digit number for
your subject, you have a lot of options for which boat you can choose to build. However- be sure not to mix up the “6” and “9”, as the shading only
goes one way, and you can’t just turn a “6” upside-down to make a “9”, as the shading will be reversed. The kit is actually pretty accurate with only a
few small discrepancies that were pointed out by Al Ross in a review that he did at an earlier date.  He rightly noted that the torpedo fins should have a
slant to them rather than being perfectly square, but I did not change them for this build. I also would like to thank Al for sending me the correct
drawing to indicate how to apply the underside color and waterline. I initially had it wrong, but changed it with Al’s help. In conclusion, despite a few
rather minor glitches and discrepancies, I am very impressed with the kit overall and enjoyed building it.  Even a novice can make this kit into an
impressive finished product merely by following the instructions carefully and taking time to dry-fit the components before assembly. Thanks to Garth
Connelly and Tony Chin from Merit for providing me with the kit and paints, to Tracy White for his input and feedback, and to Al Ross for his technical
assistance.
Bob Cicconi
____________________________________________________________________